Birthing Center vs Hospital : Advantages & Disadvantages

When it comes to having a baby, expectant parents have the choice between birthing centers and hospitals. Many factors come into play when deciding where to have a baby, such as the cost of services, the level of care available, and the comfort level of family members. Ultimately, parents need to weigh all their options and decide what is best for them and their baby. This article looks at what sets birthing centers apart from hospitals so that expectant parents can make an informed choice.

Definition of Birthing Centers and Hospitals

What is a Birthing Center?

 Birthing Centers are typically standalone, free-standing facilities that offer a more home-like environment for childbirth. They promote natural birthing and strive to keep interventions to a minimum. Most birthing centers provide labor support such as massage, water therapy, aromatherapy, hypnobirthing, and other comfort measures.

What is a Hospitals?

Hospitals are medical institutions where healthcare services are provided to patients. Hospitals offer various maternity care services, including labor and delivery, postpartum care, lactation support, and newborn assessments. Hospitals typically have more resources and technology available for interventions such as Cesarean sections than birthing centers do. Hospitals can also handle high-risk pregnancies requiring specialized care not offered in birthing centers.

Advantage of Birthing Centers vs. Hospitals

Birthing Centers

• Home-like Environment

Birthing centers provide a much more relaxed and intimate setting than a hospital. The focus is on providing natural childbirth options with minimal interventions, and the environment is designed to create a calming atmosphere for labor and delivery.

• Cost Efficient

Generally, birthing centers are less expensive than hospitals as they offer fewer amenities, such as private rooms and lactation consultants.

• More Personalized Care

Birthing centers are usually staffed by midwives and doulas who provide more personalized pre-natal, labor, delivery, postpartum and newborn care. Many birthing centers offer classes to help educate couples on pregnancy, birth options, breastfeeding, and parenting.

• Fewer Interventions

Birthing centers promote natural childbirth and strive to keep interventions minimal. They provide labor support such as massage, water therapy, aromatherapy, hypnobirthing, and other comfort measures.

• Natural Birthing Options

Birthing centers offer various natural birthing options such as water birth, delayed cord clamping, and lotus birth.

• Participation

The couple is encouraged to participate in childbirth at a birthing center. They are allowed to move around during labor and choose their positions for delivery.

• Doula Support

Many birthing centers provide trained doulas who serve as labor coaches, providing emotional and physical support to the couple during childbirth.


• Emergency Access

Hospitals are equipped with staff and necessary resources for medical interventions in case of emergency during labor and delivery.

• Specialized Care

Hospitals offer specialized care to handle high-risk pregnancies that cannot be managed at a birthing center due to the limited staff and resources.

• Variety of Services

Hospitals provide various maternity care services, including labor and delivery, postpartum care, lactation support, and newborn assessments.

• Comfort

Hospitals usually have private rooms with all the amenities of a traditional hospital, such as cable TV and Wi-Fi.

• More Technology

Hospitals have access to more advanced technology compared to birthing centers for interventions like Cesarean sections or forceps deliveries if needed.

• Insurance Coverage

Most health insurance plans cover hospital births. This is not usually the case with birthing centers, where couples may pay out-of-pocket for services.

• Comprehensive Support

Hospitals typically have in-house lactation consultants, pediatricians, and other specialists available to provide comprehensive care during and after delivery.

Disadvantages- Birthing Center vs. Hospital

Birthing Centers

• Limited Resources:

Birthing centers typically have fewer resources than hospitals which means they cannot accommodate high-risk pregnancies or emergencies that require specialized care.

• Fewer Interventions Available

Many birthing centers practice natural birthing and strive to keep interventions such as inductions and epidurals to a minimum.

• Limited Staffing

Birthing centers usually have less medical staff available than hospitals which may make it difficult for them to provide necessary care during labor and delivery.

• No Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU)

Birthing centers typically don’t have a NICU, so if there are any complications with the baby, they will need to be transferred to a hospital for specialized care.

• Geographical Restrictions

Birthing centers are unavailable in every area, so you may need to travel further away from home if you decide to use one.


• Clinical Environment

Hospitals often have a clinical environment that may not be as relaxing as the environment in a birthing center.

• More Interventions Available

Hospitals can provide interventions such as Cesarean sections and labor inductions that may not be available in some birthing centers.

• Higher Cost

Since hospitals have more resources, they tend to charge more for services than birthing centers do.

• More Medical Staff

Hospitals typically have more medical staff available to provide care during labor and delivery, which may be intimidating for some women.

• Less Control

Women may not feel as much control over their birth experience in a hospital because of the number of medical personnel involved and the presence of technology such as monitors and IVs.


Is it safe to give birth at a birth Centre?

Yes, it is generally safe to give birth at a birthing center. Birthing centers are staffed by trained professionals who use evidence-based practices to provide safe care during labor and delivery. However, suppose you have any medical complications or high-risk pregnancy issues. In that case, it may be safer to deliver in a hospital where more resources are available for intervention if needed.

Where is the safest place to give birth?

The safest place to give birth is the place that best meets your individual needs and preferences. For some women, this may be a hospital where they can access specialized care for any complications or medical issues during labor and delivery. For other women, a birthing center may provide a quieter, more relaxed environment with fewer interventions and more personalized attention.

What is the safest way to give birth?

The safest way to give birth is the one that works best for you. Talk with your doctor or midwife about your options, and discuss any potential risks involved in each option. The most common options include vaginal delivery, Cesarean section, and water birth.

do birthing centers have epidurals? 

Generally, birthing centers strive to keep interventions like epidurals to a minimum and focus more on natural childbirth methods. However, some centers may provide options for medical pain relief if needed. Talk with your doctor or midwife about your options at the birthing center you are considering.

Does insurance cover hospital births?

Yes, most health insurance plans cover hospital births. Check with your provider to confirm what is covered, and understand any out-of-pocket costs that may be involved.

does insurance cover birthing centers? 

Birthing centers are usually not covered by insurance, so you may have to pay for services out-of-pocket. Check with your provider or the birthing center about payment options before making a decision.

Final Words

When it comes to choosing where to give birth, the decision should be based on what is best for you and your baby. Birthing centers offer a quieter, more natural setting, while hospitals are better equipped to handle high-risk pregnancies or any complications that may arise during labor and delivery. It is essential to familiarize yourself with both options before making a decision and ask any questions you may have to ensure that you are selecting the best choice for your needs.

Leave a Comment